Correction/Mythes et héros
Cours gratuits > Forum > Forum anglais: Questions sur l'anglais || En basCorrection/Mythes et héros
Message de berylou posté le 23-02-2015 à 16:31:07 (S | E | F)
Bonjour
dans quelques jours je vais passer un oral blanc d'anglais sur Mythes et héros; je l'ai rédigé mais , comme je fais beaucoup de fautes même si je me relis , j'aimerais bien un petit coup de pouce (si quelqu'un a le temps ).
Merci d'avance à toute personne qui accepterait de me corriger ,ce serait super sympa.
Myths and heroes
I will speak about the notion of myths and heroes threw the Lord of the Rings . We can notice various heroes in this novel but I’ve chosen to focuse on Sam’s character . We can wonder in which way Sam is he a hero . First we will see Sam’s qualities and then how thanks to his qualities Sam becomes a hero .
1.First of all in document 1, although Sam only says 1 sentence ,we can see he is helpful and faithful to Frodo . Indeed he refuses to let him alone in this quest as is evidenced l.13 :”But you won’t send him off alone surely.” He is ready to follow Frodo even if he is terrified by the quest as is noticed in document 2 l.7 :”And after all he never had any real hope in this affair from the beginning” and even if he would have preferred to stay in Shire because hobbits are stay-at-home . In fact Sam displays all the qualities of a good servant: -first he respects and serves Frodo
-secondly he is very competent
-thirdly he is always taking care of material things
-finally he protects his master .
Frodo wouldn't have gotten very far without Sam
He shows us the pure meaning of friendship and true courage .Indeed because he is convinced that he has to be with Frodo until the end, he follows his friend though he is not concerned at all by the quest :
- he isn’t the ring bearer
-he hasn’t sworn anything to Frodo.
The only reason why he takes part of the quest he as a friend and a servant of Frodo . He is disinterested .Thus we can see Sam has the sense of duty.
In document 3 we can see Sam is realistic ,down to hearth and humble. He recognizes he can’t become a powerful person as is proved l.11 :”He knew in the core of his heart that he wasn’t large enough to bear such a burden (….)
2.Now we are going to see why Sam can be considered as a hero with document 3 .The lord of the Rings is a novel dealing with the renunciation of power . This extract shows us Sam is able to reject the temptation of the Ring . this temptation lets him 2 choices :
- to abstain from using the Ring
- or to keep it and become “Samwise the Strong , Hero of the Age (….)” .
However thanks to his humility and his affection for Frodo ,Sam isn’t corrupt by the Ring. He isn’t interested at all in power that’s why the Ring has no control on him . The only ambition of Sam is a small garden as we can from l.11 to 14 . As a consequence Sam is the perfect example of renouncing power .
Sam is also the main character of the Lord of the Rings since he is the person who illustrate the most the topic of the novel .
In a letter to Milton Waldman (so-called Letter 131), Tolkien makes mention of Sam being the "chief hero" of the story [1]:”I think the simple 'rustic' love of Sam and his Rosie (nowhere elaborated) is absolutely essential to the study of his (the chief hero's) character, and to the theme of the relation of ordinary life (breathing, eating, working, begetting) and quests, sacrifice, causes, and the 'longing for Elves', and sheer beauty heroicy .”
To conclude Sam is a hero not only thanks to hi s qualities but also because he his the main character of the novel . We know that Tolkien get inspired by the soldier of the first world war who are heroes as they offered their life to save population and country.
-------------------
Modifié par lucile83 le 23-02-2015 18:57
Message de berylou posté le 23-02-2015 à 16:31:07 (S | E | F)
Bonjour
dans quelques jours je vais passer un oral blanc d'anglais sur Mythes et héros; je l'ai rédigé mais , comme je fais beaucoup de fautes même si je me relis , j'aimerais bien un petit coup de pouce (si quelqu'un a le temps ).
Merci d'avance à toute personne qui accepterait de me corriger ,ce serait super sympa.
Myths and heroes
I will speak about the notion of myths and heroes threw the Lord of the Rings . We can notice various heroes in this novel but I’ve chosen to focuse on Sam’s character . We can wonder in which way Sam is he a hero . First we will see Sam’s qualities and then how thanks to his qualities Sam becomes a hero .
1.First of all in document 1, although Sam only says 1 sentence ,we can see he is helpful and faithful to Frodo . Indeed he refuses to let him alone in this quest as is evidenced l.13 :”But you won’t send him off alone surely.” He is ready to follow Frodo even if he is terrified by the quest as is noticed in document 2 l.7 :”And after all he never had any real hope in this affair from the beginning” and even if he would have preferred to stay in Shire because hobbits are stay-at-home . In fact Sam displays all the qualities of a good servant: -first he respects and serves Frodo
-secondly he is very competent
-thirdly he is always taking care of material things
-finally he protects his master .
Frodo wouldn't have gotten very far without Sam
He shows us the pure meaning of friendship and true courage .Indeed because he is convinced that he has to be with Frodo until the end, he follows his friend though he is not concerned at all by the quest :
- he isn’t the ring bearer
-he hasn’t sworn anything to Frodo.
The only reason why he takes part of the quest he as a friend and a servant of Frodo . He is disinterested .Thus we can see Sam has the sense of duty.
In document 3 we can see Sam is realistic ,down to hearth and humble. He recognizes he can’t become a powerful person as is proved l.11 :”He knew in the core of his heart that he wasn’t large enough to bear such a burden (….)
2.Now we are going to see why Sam can be considered as a hero with document 3 .The lord of the Rings is a novel dealing with the renunciation of power . This extract shows us Sam is able to reject the temptation of the Ring . this temptation lets him 2 choices :
- to abstain from using the Ring
- or to keep it and become “Samwise the Strong , Hero of the Age (….)” .
However thanks to his humility and his affection for Frodo ,Sam isn’t corrupt by the Ring. He isn’t interested at all in power that’s why the Ring has no control on him . The only ambition of Sam is a small garden as we can from l.11 to 14 . As a consequence Sam is the perfect example of renouncing power .
Sam is also the main character of the Lord of the Rings since he is the person who illustrate the most the topic of the novel .
In a letter to Milton Waldman (so-called Letter 131), Tolkien makes mention of Sam being the "chief hero" of the story [1]:”I think the simple 'rustic' love of Sam and his Rosie (nowhere elaborated) is absolutely essential to the study of his (the chief hero's) character, and to the theme of the relation of ordinary life (breathing, eating, working, begetting) and quests, sacrifice, causes, and the 'longing for Elves', and sheer beauty heroicy .”
To conclude Sam is a hero not only thanks to hi s qualities but also because he his the main character of the novel . We know that Tolkien get inspired by the soldier of the first world war who are heroes as they offered their life to save population and country.
-------------------
Modifié par lucile83 le 23-02-2015 18:57
Réponse: Correction/Mythes et héros de here4u, postée le 24-02-2015 à 00:08:58 (S | E)
Hello
I'll start ...
Myths and heroes
I will speak about the notion of myths and heroes threw the Lord of the Rings . We can notice various heroes in this novel but I’ve chosen to focuse on Sam’s character . We can wonder in which way Sam is
1.First of all in document 1, although Sam only says 1 sentence ,we can see he is helpful and faithful to Frodo . Indeed he refuses to let him alone in this quest as is evidenced l.13 :”But you won’t send him off alone surely.” He is ready to follow Frodo even if he is terrified by the quest as is noticed in document 2 l.7 :”And after all he never had any real hope in this affair from the beginning” (and) even if he would have preferred to stay in Shire because hobbits are stay-at-home . In fact Sam displays all the qualities of a good servant: - first he respects and serves Frodo
-secondly he is very competent
-thirdly he is always taking care of material things
-finally he protects his master .
Frodo wouldn't have gotten very far without Sam
He shows us the pure meaning of friendship and true courage .Indeed because he is convinced that he has to be with Frodo until the end, he follows his friend though he is not concerned at all by the quest :
- he isn’t the ring bearer
-he hasn’t sworn anything to Frodo.
The only reason why he takes part of the quest he as a friend and a servant of Frodo . He is disinterested .Thus we can see Sam has (the) a sense of duty.
In document 3 we can see Sam is realistic ,down to hearth and humble. He recognizes he can’t become a powerful person as is proved l.11 :”He knew in the core of his heart that he wasn’t large enough to bear such a burden (….)
2.Now we are going to see why Sam can be considered as a hero with document 3 .The lord of the Rings is a novel dealing with the renunciation of power . This extract shows us Sam is able to reject the temptation of the Ring . this temptation lets him XXX 2 choices :
- to abstain from using the Ring
- or to keep it and become “Samwise the Strong , Hero of the Age (….)” .
However thanks to his humility and his affection for Frodo ,Sam isn’t corrupted by the Ring. He isn’t interested at all in power that’s why the Ring has no control on him . The only ambition of Sam is a small garden as we can V ??? from l.11 to 14 . As a consequence Sam is the perfect example of renouncing power .
Sam is also the main character of the Lord of the Rings since he is the person who illustrate the most the topic of the novel .
In a letter to Milton Waldman (so-called Letter 131), Tolkien
To conclude Sam is a hero not only thanks to his qualities but also because he his the main character of the novel . We know that Tolkien get inspired by the soldier of the first world war who are heroes as they offered their life to save population and country.
Hope it'll help! (de toute évidence, certains passages sont recopiés de York Notes or equivalent!!! )
Cours gratuits > Forum > Forum anglais: Questions sur l'anglais
